Forum Thread

Mafia 2.0

Forum-Index → Forum Games → Mafia 2.0

Maria-chan

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 27

Forum Posts: 51

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 01:51                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

They were not lynched, so I believe that doctor actually can heal someone even if they died the same night. Other roles can do that, so why wouldn't the doctor be able to?
Not saying for sure that you are lying about being doctor, but I do not quite trust it.

~Maria-chan~
Please help me level him up.~

Show hidden content

Nekomaru_Nidai

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 55

Forum Posts: 1,276

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 01:54                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

I mean, obviously they would heal someone before dying. But actions were listed as the Goon killing them first. The Doctor didn't heal first and then die.

Anyway, I could prove it next night if you want, but I don't think I'm going to last long after this.

Maria-chan

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 27

Forum Posts: 51

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:02                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

In general, order of actions does not matter other than lynching has priority over everything. We had this discussion in prior rounds due to moderators not knowing this (otherwise people in time zones different from the moderator would be at a disadvantage due to being more likely to put in their roles later). Also, from what I can see, Majikal is most likely just putting in the actions in the order he received them (orders are inconsistent, so this is the only way I can see that happening). As such, I don't think it proves anything, assuming my interpretation of this is correct.

Again, it's not certain you are lying, though the lack of any night having 2 doctor actions seems odd since Frisco actually was active.

~Maria-chan~
Please help me level him up.~

Show hidden content

Maria-chan

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 27

Forum Posts: 51

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:08                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

I was typing this when Great_Days made his claim, finally got around to finishing typing it (I had 3 tabs open to just this forum, lol - typing this, typing a response to Great_Days, and reading things in the forum in order to make sure I kept track of things correctly for both)

So, while a good third of the players did not talk N1, more did begin to talk later.
However, unless I missed it these people have said nothing since the round restart:
Minhyuk
Zuramaru
Awesomegokul
Prim
Croscx

Some other people talked, but said very little:
Mavis_Vermilion has only talked once, and was not really on topic of determining anything (talked about the Facestabbers original intended purpose.
Pokekitten talked once to abstain, but that is it.
Professor_Mac was in the discussion about how MrBean still dies from being lynched even if he is healed, but has not talked outside of it.
Bpeugh1 only talked in Night 2, primarily in the incredibly off topic discussion of cheese.

As you can see, quite a few people have been inactive, so determining a specific suspicious person will be a challenge.

~Maria-chan~
Please help me level him up.~

Show hidden content

Nekomaru_Nidai

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 55

Forum Posts: 1,276

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:11                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

I don't see it that way. Order of actions don't have priority, but life does. Call me illogical if I think you can't act after dead xD. When I was overseer, if goon acted before Doctor and Doctor's action was relevant, I healed first and the kill. As you say it would be unfair if it wasn't this way.

In any case, it's okay. I can save myself again. I'm going to bed now, I'd like to talk about lynching but I'm tired ^^'

Maria-chan

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 27

Forum Posts: 51

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:14                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

Okay, good night~

~Maria-chan~
Please help me level him up.~

Show hidden content

Uzumaki

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 23

Forum Posts: 46

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:17                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

Omg sorry guys!!! I have been traveling all weekend and have not had internet. What have I missed?

Nanbaka Trash:

Show hidden content

Maria-chan

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 27

Forum Posts: 51

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:30                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

So, on the previous page I have a massive set of lists of all night actions and votes, as well as who is alive and dead if you want details, but here is a summary.

You talked early N2, so I assume you at least looked at the N1 results.
N2:
Vigilante shot me - I was cop and to Majikal's entertainment I had chosen to investigate them like 30 seconds earlier.
Goon killed XtremeGaming - he was a townie
Reviver revived Suvichan
no other mafia acted, no lynch

Discussion:They spent most of the night in an off-topic discussion, so there is not any important info there.

N3:
meme was lynched - he was guard
goon killed Frisco - he was doctor
Reviver revived me
no other mafia acted

Discussion: Pineapple was suspected, claimed jailkeeper. He told us beforehand who he would jail and that person was jailed, so he is probably telling the truth.
They told Majikal to make nights a little longer than they were before.

N4 so far:
Great_Days claimed that he is a second doctor, claimed that because someone was healed and it was written down after Frisco's death in the night summary that it was evidence that there must be a second doctor. However, based on what I have seen of how Majikal writes it is just the order that actions were submitted in and thus does not prove anything. The fact that both were active earlier nights but no night had 2 doctor actions makes me suspicious of his claims. He said he will heal himself tonight, so I guess we will see tonight.

Edit: I didn't realize how long my summary was until after I posted it, lol. I don't know how to explain things concisely, apparently, but it is still way shorter than reading my lists and includes discussion, so yeah.

~Maria-chan~
Please help me level him up.~

Show hidden content

TheMadScientist

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 61

Forum Posts: 169

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:51                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

There are multiple roles this time.

Edit: Somethings stop my orders

Example

1:23 A decides to kill C

1:24 B wants to spy on D

1:25 C heals B

1:26 D kills B

As A acted first C is dead.

C being dead can't heal B, so D kills B.

PokemonMaster2308

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 22

Forum Posts: 13

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:55                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

Exciting!

Clever thinking majikal

Please help my duo on fortnite battle royale

Mrinja

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 43

Forum Posts: 550

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 02:59                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

I'm voting Pokekitten. They're most likely part of the mafia, and if they're vigilante Maria_Chan can just convince us to not vote them. But with the doctor, jailkeeper, and vigilante. known and guard dead. It seems odd the nights they aren't on the goon doesn't attack and vice versa.

Though it seems like on night 2 they attacked still but didn't vote so I don't really know.

People often think the PH sprites are bland. Do they shade? Well, yes they do. You'll be surprised how much care is taken for these sprites.

Maria-chan

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 27

Forum Posts: 51

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:14                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

So I guess Great_Days is telling the truth.

Also, no Pokekitten is not the vigilante I checked (Majikal said repeat roles are present, so it is possible there is a second vigilante somewhere).

Why do you say they are most likely mafia?

~Maria-chan~
Please help me level him up.~

Show hidden content

PokemonMaster2308

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 22

Forum Posts: 13

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:15                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

At least we know someone who knows vig so we have more support for who to not lynch

Please help my duo on fortnite battle royale

bpeugh1

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 77

Forum Posts: 86

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:15                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

Mac and cheezles

~Brian Austin Peugh

PokemonMaster2308

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 22

Forum Posts: 13

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:16                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

Dont bring cheese back up:,( :,( :,(

Please help my duo on fortnite battle royale

bpeugh1

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 77

Forum Posts: 86

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:20                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

I always bring up the cheesiest of topics :P

~Brian Austin Peugh

Maria-chan

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 27

Forum Posts: 51

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:22                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

If cheese comes back up, I am suspecting bpeugh1 for derailing our discussion away from potential suspicions. Please stop.

~Maria-chan~
Please help me level him up.~

Show hidden content

Suvichan

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 36

Forum Posts: 570

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:53                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

Hi
So I got revived?

What all happened guys?

This awesome art and Avatar is made by Grietine! Visit her deviantart.

Lyney

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 54

Forum Posts: 636

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:57                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

I think I would just normally vote for them if they derail the convo again

Or yknow, sorcerer

”Mysterious… surprising… and law-defying… Isn’t that right?”

XtremeGaming

OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 34

Forum Posts: 167

                                                Posted: Sun, 15/04/2018 03:58                                                (6 Years ago)
                                            

~~Wevive meh pweaaaaseee~~