Forum Thread

Heroathlon

The Heroathlon Dome is a small area which contains a variety of features. First is the dome itself, where you can partake in a variety of Pokéathlon Games. This dome also has shops changing depending on the day.
if you want more information see in this site,i cant put the image :(.
the site

---

8) plz comment here

---

No support. We already have the mall that sells various items and goods listed in that list you linked to, from the battle shop to sell protein to the item shop to sell Evo stones and berries. But some stuff doesn't even apply to Pokeheroes, like PP restores, Full Restores, Apricorns, ect. at least not yet.

As for games we already have the lottery, the slot machine, the treasure hunt, all of which have a chance for providing various items and money to buy items. So, you can either win these items or buy them.

---

No support. Why? If you want to make a suggestion that is so huge like this and you want people to support, you have to provide specific examples. No, don't say "the same games as the PokéAthlon," because not all of those are as easy to use on a web browser as on a DS and there HAVE to be some changes - instead, say something like "for example, that Snowball Fight mini game from the PokéAthlon is used, and you click and drag snowballs onto enemies like in the Gem Cauldron." I don't mean using that exact example, because it is a terrible idea that I thought of solely to provide an example, but something like that. You have to provide examples right down to the controls, or people won't know WHAT they're supporting and very few people will support.
Add to that the fact that, as Queen Pumpkaboo said, all of the items you wanted are already available in many other ways. Would it not make more sense to give Game Chips to winners? Like the points in the games, you win them for playing games and can exchange them for prizes. It just makes more sense to use Game Chips as prizes because Game Chips are already on PH, already have designated prizes that were well thought out, and are just better than giving prizes that were chosen in the games, for the games, and are good prizes only in the games. PokéHeroes have Game Chips, which were chosen on PH, for PH, and are good prizes on PH. If this suggestion IS approved (and the lack of detail means that it probably won't unless it is changed drastically), I think it should use Game Chips, not some irrelevant currency that did the same thing in the games for less useful prizes.

---

No Support!

Like Carpet said, this lacks detail. You never said what we would do in the dome, you never said how it would work, you never gave detail about the dome, and you never said what the point if the dome is.

I'd like to ask you the question of how this would even work or get incorporated.

Certain items on that list you showed aren't even obtainable in Pokeheroes. Not only that, how will Pokemon compete in these games. HG & SS had their own special stats for Pokemon specifically for the dome, and these stats could be changed with Apricorn juice, which we don't have. Please specify your post and maybe I'll support this

---

Uhm... Since you added TheBeast, I think it is safe to assume that your list was supposed to be fully updated, so why was am I not on the list of non-supporters when he is?
Also, I don't think the list of support/no support is even necessary. The staff doesn't just look at how many people do or don't support - they actually see who made a more convincing argument. The list will be ignored in favor of actually reading the thread. If you think they do consider the list, it means you chose not to add me in order to make it look like fewer people were against it than in reality; if you don't think they consider it, the list really isn't needed.
(That aside, since you DID obviously see our posts, is there any particular reason why you didn't address any of my concerns? Given that you didn't reply, didn't edit your post, and didn't even add me to the list of people who don't support, it seems like you're basically acting as though my post didn't exist. >.>)

---

a suggestion this big will warrant looking through the actual posts of users, and no one looks at the 'supports' or 'non supports' to determine whether something will be accepted anyways - i've deleted this from the main post to avoid the problem of ignoring users that seems to be popping up so the actual suggestion can be concentrated on

---

Such a huge feature requires more than just a link to a serebii-article to know what you're actually suggesting.
It's obvious, that these Pokeathlon games can not be implemented like in the games - in the games they are mainly played with the touchscreen, and this is much easier than playing such games with the mouse. So please elaborate your suggestion a bit more next time - only because you liked the feature in the original games (which I did, too, by the way), doesn't mean that we need exactly the same on PokéHeroes. Because... well they already exist in an almost perfect way in HG/SS.

Apart from that, I'm sometimes wondering if some people are actually thinking about the suggestion before posting a "Support!". Recently it seems like some suggestions are always supported by some players, just for the sake of getting updates, updates, updates... But in fact, getting higher quality updates is much better than... well, lower quality features. More supported suggestions doesn't mean that the amount of new features increases; in fact I'm working for PH nearly every day; I'm not just sitting here, waiting for new ideas.

---